February 2026 Carlisle Real Estate Market Statistics and Home Sales

Here is a look at our Real Estate Market for the entire month of February 2026. Overall, the local market demonstrated mixed results compared to the same time last year (2025). While the total number of homes sold saw a significant increase, the median sale price experienced a decline, reflecting a shifting dynamic in our area as we head toward the spring selling season.

Sales Statistics:

Total Home Closings:

38 sales (Up from 27 in 2025)

Median Sale Price:

$219,250 (Down from $275,000 in 2025)

Lowest Sale Price:

$5,500 (20 Coral Drive)

Highest Sale Price:

$672,510 (125 Blue Mountain Blvd)

Homes that closed in February 2026:

Listed in order of lowest price to highest price

20 Coral Drive: $5,500 – Closed 02/20/2026
36 Marilyn Drive: $36,500 – Closed 02/12/2026
54 Cave Hill Dr: $117,500 – Closed 02/23/2026
423 W Penn St: $126,500 – Closed 02/26/2026
171 E North Street St: $128,000 – Closed 02/26/2026
138 W Church Ave: $156,500 – Closed 02/09/2026
417 Arch St: $163,000 – Closed 02/27/2026
371 Old State Rd: $165,000 – Closed 02/27/2026
251 E Pomfret St: $170,000 – Closed 02/05/2026
109 S Bedford St: $170,900 – Closed 02/20/2026
23 N Baltimore Ave: $175,000 – Closed 02/09/2026
411 N Bedford St: $175,500 – Closed 02/13/2026
145 Cedar St: $185,000 – Closed 02/10/2026
16 Courtyard Dr: $190,000 – Closed 02/13/2026
257 W Willow St: $195,000 – Closed 02/27/2026
158 Faith Circle: $200,000 – Closed 02/27/2026
1833 Spring Rd: $210,000 – Closed 02/05/2026
160 Marbeth Ave: $212,000 – Closed 02/11/2026
1052 Rebecca St: $218,500 – Closed 02/20/2026
36 White Oak Dr: $220,000 – Closed 02/02/2026
1047 Newville Rd: $230,000 – Closed 02/13/2026
438 N Pitt St: $241,000 – Closed 02/04/2026
648 N College St: $259,900 – Closed 02/06/2026
910 W Louther St: $284,900 – Closed 02/24/2026
23 Debra Ln #53B: $298,985 – Closed 02/05/2026
430 N Hanover St: $320,000 – Closed 02/06/2026
1913 Maplewood Drive: $320,000 – Closed 02/20/2026
970 Cranes Gap Rd: $335,000 – Closed 02/20/2026
51 Bennington Way: $370,000 – Closed 02/02/2026
628 Belvedere St: $380,000 – Closed 02/27/2026
508 Burnt House Rd: $401,000 – Closed 02/13/2026
21 American Ave: $417,000 – Closed 02/04/2026
929 W North St: $424,900 – Closed 02/18/2026
24 American Ave: $438,990 – Closed 02/21/2026
250 Mooreland Ave: $590,000 – Closed 02/20/2026
127 Blue Mountain Blvd: $629,809 – Closed 02/10/2026
100 Richland Rd: $655,000 – Closed 02/03/2026
125 Blue Mountain Blvd: $672,510 – Closed 02/06/2026

Information is deemed reliable and correct, but is not guaranteed. Data comes from Bright MLS and is for the entire Carlisle School District.